|
|
|
       |
|
|

Simonds Red Streak Booklet.
Narrow Kerf
Bandsaw Blades.

The purpose of this booklet is to provide you a better
understanding of the factors that impact narrow kerf bandsaw blade performance.
Necessarily, much of the discussion centers around the machinery used and
species sawn as well as the saw blades themselves.
Multiple head narrow kerf bandsaw technology is relatively
new. While the use of narrow bands in the furniture industry has a long history,
the current practice of using narrow bandsaw blades for high production pallet
stock manufacturing is less than five years old. Use of narrow kerf bandsaw
blades on "portable sawmills" is less than ten years old. Given the fast paced
development of both machine and saw blade technology for these markets,
subsequent re-prints and update of this booklet are inevitable. Having stated
that, what follows is the best of what is available today to help you get the
most out of your narrow kerf bandsaw blades.
Saw Blades
The narrow kerf bandsaw blades used on multiple head resaws,
single head resaws, scragg machines and portable sawmills are generally
available in three different widths- 1", 1-1/4" and 2" wide. Blade thickness is
generally either .035" or .042". Certainly other widths and thickness are used
in specialty applications, but these represent the majority used today.
The most common type of saw blade used for narrow kerf
bandsawing is a carbon steel blade. Carbon Steel blades are available with three
different heat treatments and hardness conditions- Constant Hardness, Flex Back
(also referred to as Hard Edge) and Hard Back. The alternative to carbon steel
blades would be Simonds Porta-Pro specialty blades with carbide, Stellite or
high-speed steel Teeth. .
Constant Hardness- The entire width of the blade has the
same hardness. This type of blade usually has a hardness of 45-48 on the
Rockwell C Scale. The low carbon steel used for this type of saw has very good
flex life, but cannot be heat treated to the higher hardness of the other types
of saws. This degree of hardness is approximately the same as you would find on
conventional swage tooth wide bandsaws and is sufficient for cutting most wood
species.
Flex Back- Hard Edge- This type of saw is commonly
referred to by either of these two names. The steel alloy used to produce Flex
Back type Saws- and Hard Back saws as well- has a higher carbon content than the
steel used for constant hardness saws. The cutting edge of this type of saw
blade is hardened to approximately 63-65 on the Rockwell C scale. This hardness
carries down approximately half the height of the tooth. The body of this type
of saw blade is at the as rolled hardness, usually 30-33 Rockwell C. An
advantage of this type of blade over Constant Hardness saws is the harder
cutting edge will stay sharp longer. The softer body resists fatigue cracks and
works well on bandsaw machines with relatively small wheels, under 30". You may
occasionally see a black line along the back edge of a flex back saw. This is a
heat line produced during the manufacturing process to ensure proper
straightening of the blade. Do not confuse this with a Hard Back type saw which
will be discussed later.
Hard Back- this is generally the premium type of carbon bandsaw blade.
The cutting edge of the saw is heat treated to 63-65 Rockwell. This, in effect,
results in a spring temper for the back of the saw. The additional heat
treatment increases the tensile strength of the blade over %0% and results in
the ability to withstand higher tension and feed speeds. This dual heat treat
produces a saw with a hardened long lasting cutting edge and a stiff straight
cutting body.
Porta-Pro Specialty Blades- For the purposes of this
booklet, Specialty Blades include carbide tipped- Stellite tipped, and high
speed steel tipped bandsaw blades. The principle behind specialty bandsaw blades
is they combine the superior flex life of a low carbon steel backer with the
edge holding ability of an exotic allow. Due to the more involved manufacturing
process for these saw blades, the cost is significantly higher than carbon steel
blades. Specialty blades have proven to be economical only in relatively
specialized applications. One or two blades that break before they get dull can
quickly wipe out any potential savings or benefit.
Choosing the Proper Saw
One fact must be accepted before we can proceed with the
discussion of which blade to choose. All bandsaw blades will eventually fatigue
and break. A blade, which never produces a foot of boards will eventually break
if, put on the bandsaw machine and allowed to run. This is a function of the
Flex Life of the steel. The efficient sawyer chooses a saw blade which yields
the best balance of Flex Life and edge holding ability.
The two extremes would be a saw still sharp when it fatigues
and breaks and a saw that dulls quickly and wont cut, but also will not break.
Each of the four types of saws have their advantages and no one blade is best
for all applications.
Constant Hardness blades have good flex life, but dull
relatively quickly. As a result, this type of saw blade is useful in low to
moderate production applications such as on portable saw mills.
A bandsaw blade on a portable sawmill is generally "in the
cut" less relative to the number of times it rotates around the wheels than you
would find no a multiple head resaw. As a result, edge-holding ability is often
seen as secondary to flex life in this application. It is certainly not
economical to replace a sharp blade that fatigued and broke due to poor flex
life. An alternative to constant hardness saws on a portable saw mills is the
flex back blade. Flex back blades offer the superior edge holding ability of a
heat-treated blade. The relatively soft body of the saw compensates for the
higher carbon content and gives satisfactory fatigue or flex life.
Flex Back blades have very good edge holding ability. The
relatively soft nature of the body of the blade enables it to run successfully
on very small band wheels. Flex back blades are economical to use and will also
perform very well in multiple head resaw applications. Flex back blades can be
re-sharpened. However, due to the soft body of the blade, once the saw has been
ground past the heat-treated tooth area, the blades must be discarded.
Hard Back blades, like flex back, have very good edge
holding ability. The hardened backer also results in a stiffer blade that
provide very straight cuts even under the highest feed rates. Hard Back blades
can be re-sharpened many times. Even once ground past the tooth hardened area,
the backer is sufficiently hard, as hard as constant hardness blades, to
satisfactorily cut wood. Hard back blades should not be used on machines with
small wheels, under 30", as body cracks may develop.
Various specialty blades have been developed to meet the
specific needs of some unique operations. Simonds Porta-Pro specialty bands are
available with Stellite tips, Carbide tips and High Speed Steel tips. The
practicality of these specialized and more expensive to purchase saw blades
must, of course, be determined by the user. Generally speaking, use of these
specialty blades is restricted to a minority of users and will not be discussed
in any great detail in this edition of this booklet. Should you determine carbon
bandsaw blades are not the most economical or efficient saw for you, then you
may consider using these more exotic blades.
Re-Sharpening
The preceding paragraphs mention re-sharpening narrow kerf
bandsaw blades. The practicality of re-sharpening blades really comes down to a
question of time and economics.
Most narrow kerf bandsaw machine owners calculate their cost
per outwits the knowledge that the bandsaw blade is a "throw away". Others
at-tempt to control bandsaw costs through the use of resharpened blades. These
are the two school of thought when it comes to minimizing narrow kerf bandsaw
blade costs, resharpening and not re-sharpening. The "best" approach will depend
primarily on your labor costs.
One school of thought is to run blades as long as feasible,
minimize ''down time", and dispose of the blades when they get too dull to run
or eventually
fatigue and break. Following this method, the mill need not
concern itself with maintenance equipment, or expensive down time from
inconsistent lengths of run time. New blades will, if properly welded and
properly handled, all run for approximately the same length of time before
failure. This allows for scheduled blade changes and minimal mid-shift down
time. Unscheduled downtime, a common problem with resharpened blades, can
quickly wipe out blade cost savings by idling workers. The key to success when
not resharpening is to purchasable best quality, most consistent bandsaw blades
possible and to minimize purchase costs.
The second school of thought is to resharpen bandsaw blades.
Done properly, this can be a very economical way to run a narrow kerf bandsaw
operation. There are two main points to consider when deciding whether or not to
resharpen narrow kerf bandsaw blades.
Point 1. Labor and Maintenance Cost. How much does your
labor, both your own and/or your employees cost per hour, wages and fringes?
Will your resharpening employee be idles most of the time, or do you now have an
under-utilized employee with the aptitude to do your resharpening work? Labor
costs must be evaluated with consideration of how many blades will be
resharpened by the employee per hour. Other costs the mill must evaluate are
identification and acquisition of quality resharpening equipment, grinding
wheels, inspection gauges, etc. Mill owners mankind that the true cost of a
resharpened blade is not significantly less than that of a factory new blade.
And, of course, a resharpened blade may not last as long as a new one.
Point 2. Actual Benefits. Narrow kerf band-saw blades
eventually fatigue and break. Premature blade failure can be minimized through
use of as large a band wheel diameter as feasible and through proper saw guide
maintenance. It is difficult to predict how long resharpened blades will last
versus a new blade and the timing of blade failure can often determine the
economics of whether or not resharpening is worthwhile. The resharpened blade
may fail shortly after resharpening duets: steel fatigue from a blade run too
long when dull, or improperly set guides may have heated the blade, or the
employee resharpening the blade may have distorted or over heated the gullet.
As with most business decisions, accurate estimation of costs
helps ensure sound decision-making. The question management must answer is
whether the benefit of an additional run is worth the downtime that may result
from an unscheduled blade change?
Strain/Tension
One of the most frequently asked questions is "What is the
proper strain or tension for my ma-chine?" (For the purposes of this booklet,
the words 'Strain' and 'Tension' are used interchange- ably to describable
pressure used to keep the saw blade taught on the band wheels and produce a
straight cut.) This is also one of the most difficult questions to answer
directly. The correct answer is, the least amount of pressure necessary to
achieve straight cuts and prevent the saw blade from slipping on the drive
wheel. Any amount of pressure applied in excess of the amount necessary to
produce straight cuts simply leads to premature blade failure.
Since most of you reading this booklet want a number, here it
is - 25,000# - 28,000# of pressure per square inch of bandsaw material. How does
one calculate this? Generally the bandsaw machine manufacturer has calculated
this and your ma-chine owner's manual will direct you to simply en-gage a
spring, run 90 psi of air pressure, or pump a cylinder to a reading of say 2,300
on a dial indicator. As the machine operator, you can check the amount of strain
or tension your machine applies in one of two ways. You can calculate the
pressure psi based on the cylinder size, shaft size, amount of air pressure or
size of spring relative to square inches of bandsaw blade. Or, you can use a
tool called a Simometer.
A Simometer is a simple to use tool which is factory
calibrated to measure the amount of stretch a bandsaw blade experiences when the
strain is applied to a saw blade. The tool converts this into a reading on a
dial indicator. The Simometer will display the tension or strain pressure psi
your machine is applying.
While on the topic of strain, in addition to applying the
minimum amount of strain necessary to produce a straight cut, you must always
release the strain whenever you are not cutting. It serves no good purpose to
keep the saw blade under strain during dinner breaks or overnight. This is
particularly important in cold weather. A saw blade warms up while cutting and
will generally stretch. (It is good practice to check and adjust the strain
after a saw has warmed up.) As the saw cools and contracts, during a break or
overnight, it is not unusual for a blade to breaker the strain is left on the
blade.
Variables That Affect Bandsaw Blade Performance
1. Machine Operator
2. Type of Bandsaw Machine
3. Condition of Bandsaw Machine
4. The Bandsaw Wheels
5. Saw Guide Condition
6. Saw Guide Position
7. Species Being Sawn
8. Strain or Tension
9. Saw Blade Break-in and Operation
10. Saw Blade Speed and Feed Rate
11. Saw Blade Specifications 10
1. The Machine Operator
Often preached, seldom practiced, is the principle that
periodic operator re-training is a sound business practice. At the first sign of
any change in saw blade performance, it is good advice to objectively evaluate
the operating procedure. Whether youre the owner/operator, long time employee
or new hire, review your machine Owner's Manual regularly to ensure you are not
developing any bad habits or shortcuts. Most Owners Manuals contain a
troubleshooting section. The Trouble Shooting section of the Owner's Manual
should be copied and be readily available to the machine operator.
2. The Type of Bandsaw Machine
Not all bandsaw machines are engineered equal. When evaluating
the performance of a bandsaw blade, one must ensure the correct ma-chine is
being used for the application. The variety of machines available today has
resulted in considerable specialization. Ensure the machine is per-forming the
job it was engineered for, Scragg, Edger, Resaw or Log Processing.
3. The Condition Of The Machine
Both dramatic and progressive changes in saw blade-cutting
performance can often be attributed to a change in the operating condition of
the band-saw machine. Worn belts, leaky cylinders, stripped bolts, fatigued
springs, air leaks and power losses will all impact the performance of a band-
saw blade. Be sure the machine is in good working order before the type or brand
of bandsaw blade is changed. No bandsaw blade will perform satisfactorily for
any period of time on a machine in need of repair. One common problem affecting
saw blade 11
performance is the gradual wear on the equipment used to
secure the wood during the cut and wear in the tracks of machines where the saw
moves through the wood.
Should belts or hold dawns fail to secure the wood properly
you will have excess movement which can lead to blade failure.
4. The Bandsaw Wheels
The diameter and condition of the bandsaw wheels will affect
saw blade performance. Wheels of relatively small diameter, less than 25", will
generally work best with thin bandsaw blades, .035", of the hard edge type.
Larger diameter wheels afford the operator the option of using the thin blades,
choosing a thicker blade, or opting for the hard back or specialty types.
Bandsaw blade performance will also be affected by the surface
condition of the bandsaw wheels. Whether the wheels are steel or rubber covered,
the surface should be smooth and free of lumps and bumps. Bandsaw wheels must be
kept clean of waste and sawdust build up. Rubber covered wheels must be free of
cracks and chips. Steel wheels should be re-ground if excessive wear is evident.
Bandsaw blade performance is also affected by bandsaw wheel
alignment. Improper tracking, due to either poor wheel alignment or wheel wear,
is likely to result in the set being knocked out of the band, the production of
poor quality lumber and unsatisfactory blade life. Check the machine owner's
manual to ensure proper wheel alignment and tracking.
5. Saw Guide Condition
Although Saw Guide Condition is #5 on this list, followed by
Saw Guide Position at #6, when it comes to factors affecting saw blade
performance they are a principle reason for both poor blade performance and poor
quality lumber.
Worn or malfunctioning saw guides will result in premature saw
blade breakage. Roller guides that have seized will case harden the blade
resulting in cracks and breakage. Worn or improperly positioned guide blocks,
carbide, steel or composite, will allow the blade to deviate in the cut giving
poor quality lumber and broken blades.
Saw guides should be inspected on a regular basis to assure
proper clearance, no more than .003" for blocks, and free movement of roller
guides. A good start for the inspection program is at least each time a blade is
changed or twice per shift.
6. Saw Guide Position
The first component of saw guide position is relative to the
bandsaw blade. The function of the sanguine is to support the blade while
cutting. The guide should not maintain constant contact with the saw, as this
will generate heat and premature failure. The owner's manual will detail the
method of adjusting the guides. Side guides, block or roller, should have no
more than .003" clearance. This can be checked with a feeler gauge. Back guides
should be 1/32" - 1/64" away from the back of the blade. Problems will arise
from constant blade con-tact with the back guide which will lead to back edge
mushrooming, back cracks and deviations in the cut.
The second component of Saw Guide position is relative to the
work piece. Guides must be positioned to support the bandsaw blade as much as
possible during the cut. Therefore, the guide arm must be moved as close to the
log or cant as possible. Guides on portable sawmill machines should be
repositioned as the log diameter is reduced. Whenever feasible, cants and logs
should be sorted so the guide can be moved close to the narrowest cant on resaw
applications. A guide arm positioned more than 1" from the edge of the work
piece can result in uneven lumber.
7. Species Being Sawn
The vast variety of species being utilized by the lumber
industry today - and processed on narrow kerf bandsaw machines - necessitates a
realization that the same bandsaw blade on the same model machine cutting
different species or even the same species in a different environment can yield
different results. The point here is to consider species when evaluating the
performance of a bandsaw blade or bandsaw machine. Refer to the specific gravity
chart in the rear of this booklet for relative specific gravity ratings. In the
most general of terms, the higher the specific gravity of a species the more
difficult it is to cut. Bottom-line, don't expect the same performance when
cutting Hickory (.066) as when cutting Poplar.
Also consider that more side clearance is necessary in green
softwoods than in hardwoods, frozen wood or dried wood.
8. Band Strain or Tension
A definition first. Strain or tension in this con-text refers
to pounds of pressure exerted to keep 14
the band wheels apart and assure straight cuts. Do not confuse
this with Tension of a circle or wide bandsaw which refers to the stretching of
steel of these cutting tools.
Strain or tension will affect the performance of a bandsaw
blade in three ways. Too little will result in the blade slipping on the wheels,
stalling in the cut, premature blade breakage or inconsistent lumber. Too much
will result in premature blade breakage, bearing problems or excessive heat
build up. The proper amount results in an efficient productive cutting
operation. The first source for the proper amount of strain should be the
machine owner's manual. The various methods of applying this pressure - air,
hydraulics or springs - will result in many different calibration or gauge
readings on the machines. The best way to assure consistent and proper pressure
is being applied is to properly maintainers machine and periodically check
strain with a tension meter. The Simonds tension meter, called a Simometer, is
calibrated to convert the actual amount the steel is stretched, by the machine
under tension, into a dial indicator reading. Most machines and bandsaws will
run best with a reading of 25,000 - 28,000 pounds of pressure per square inch of
bandsaw blade material as measured with a Simometer.
15
9. Bandsaw Blade Break-In and Operation
All cutting tools perform best if properly broken in. It is
best to run the saw blade at approximately one half normal feed rate for the
first few cuts to hone the cutting edge. Blade will also per-form best if it is
always in the cut. Specifically, on single and multiple head resaws, it does the
band-saw blade no good to be constantly impacted by the cant. It is much better
for the feed speed to be adjusted to match the production speed. Feed the cants
butt to butt. An accelerating cant impacting the blade drives the blade into the
back guide, risks damaging the tooth and can knock the set off the blade by
having the blade ride back on the wheel.
Two other operational practices which will have and adverse
impact of the blade life are Idling and Skimming. Both of these two practices
should be kept to an absolute minimum.
Idling - Stopping the feed while a cant or log is in the cut.
This causes tooth rubbing - as opposed to cutting - and heat build up. Heat
build up and tooth rubbing will result in premature blade failure.
Skimming - Cutting with only half the blade. When a cant is
too thin for the blade to cut or the blade height is not properly set for cant
width, the blade can ride out of the cut and skim along the outside of the
board. This will damage the set on the outside of the blade, cause premature
blade failure and poor quality cuts. 16
10. Saw Blade Speed and Feed Rate
Blade speed will affect the performance
of the bandsaw blade if it is not properly coordinated with feed speed and tooth
space. Nothing is gained by running the feed speed faster than the machine
operators can handle. The results will be reduced blade life and inefficient
labor. Generally, blade speeds between 4,500 - 7,500 surface feet per minute (sfpm)
works well with most standard band- saw blade tooth spacing. Adjustments to
improve efficiency are usually accomplished with the machines variable feed
speed. You must know where your machine ''is'' before you can make informed
decisions about where to go with it - faster or slower. To check the saw blade
surface speed per minute, multiply the wheel RPM times the diameter of the wheel
in feet, times 3.14.
Bite per tooth equals teeth per minute divide by feed in
inches germinate. Teeth germinate equals teeth per foot times blade surface
speed in feet.
Example:
Blade Surface speed equals 7,000 SFPM
Decimal Equivalents
Fractions of an inch expressed as
decimals and millimeters
|
Fractional Inch
|
Decimal Inch
|
mm
|
Fractional Inch
|
Decimal Inch
|
mm
|
|
1/64
|
0.0156
|
0.3969
|
33/64
|
0.5156
|
13.0969
|
|
1/32
|
0.0313
|
0.7938
|
17/32
|
0.5313
|
13.4938
|
|
3/64
|
0.0469
|
1.1907
|
35/64
|
0.5469
|
13.8906
|
|
1/16
|
0.0625
|
1.5876
|
9/16
|
0.5625
|
14.2875
|
|
5/64
|
0.0781
|
1.9845
|
37/64
|
0.5781
|
14.6844
|
|
3/32
|
0.0938
|
2.3814
|
19/32
|
0.5938
|
15.0813
|
|
7/64
|
0.1094
|
2.7783
|
39/64
|
0.6094
|
15.4781
|
|
1/8
|
.01250
|
3.1752
|
5/8
|
0.6250
|
15.8750
|
|
9/64
|
0.1406
|
3.5721
|
41/64
|
0.6406
|
16.2719
|
|
5/32
|
0.1563
|
3.9690
|
21/32
|
0.6563
|
16.6688
|
|
11/64
|
0.1719
|
4.3659
|
43/64
|
0.6719
|
17.0656
|
|
3/16
|
0.1875
|
4.7628
|
11/16
|
0.6875
|
17.4625
|
|
13/64
|
0.2031
|
5.1597
|
45/64
|
0.7031
|
17.8594
|
|
7/32
|
0.2188
|
5.5566
|
23/32
|
0.7188
|
18.2563
|
|
15/64
|
0.2344
|
5.9535
|
47/64
|
0.7344
|
18.6531
|
|
1/4
|
0.2500
|
6.3504
|
3/4
|
0.7500
|
19.0500
|
|
17/64
|
0.2656
|
6.7473
|
49/64
|
0.7656
|
19.4469
|
|
9/32
|
0.2813
|
7.1442
|
25/32
|
0.7813
|
19.8438
|
|
19/64
|
0.2969
|
7.5411
|
51/64
|
0.7969
|
20.2406
|
|
5/16
|
0.3125
|
7.9380
|
13/16
|
0.8125
|
20.6375
|
|
21/64
|
0.3281
|
8.3349
|
53/64
|
0.8281
|
21.0344
|
|
11/32
|
0.3438
|
8.7318
|
27/32
|
0.8438
|
21.4313
|
|
23/64
|
0.3594
|
9.1287
|
55/64
|
0.8594
|
21.8281
|
|
3/8
|
0.3750
|
9.5256
|
7/8
|
0.8750
|
22.2250
|
|
25/64
|
0.3906
|
9.9225
|
57/64
|
0.8906
|
22.6219
|
|
13/32
|
0.4063
|
10.3194
|
29/32
|
0.9063
|
23.0188
|
|
27/64
|
0.4219
|
10.7193
|
59/64
|
0.8219
|
23.4156
|
|
7/16
|
0.4375
|
1.1132
|
15/16
|
0.9375
|
23.8125
|
|
29/64
|
0.4531
|
11.5101
|
61/64
|
0.9531
|
24.2094
|
|
15/32
|
0.4688
|
11.9070
|
31/32
|
0.9688
|
24.6063
|
|
31/64
|
0.4844
|
12.3039
|
63/64
|
0.9844
|
25.0031
|
|
1/2
|
0.5000
|
12.7008
|
1
|
1.0000
|
25.4000
|
Saw Gauge Decimal Equivalents
|
Saw Gauge
|
Decimal Equivalents
|
Saw Gauge
|
Decimal Equivalents
|
|
0
|
.340
|
11
|
.120
|
|
1
|
.300
|
12
|
.109
|
|
2
|
.294
|
13
|
.095
|
|
3
|
.259
|
14
|
.083
|
|
4
|
.238
|
15
|
.072
|
|
5
|
.220
|
16
|
.065
|
|
6
|
.203
|
17
|
.058
|
|
7
|
.180
|
18
|
.049
|
|
8
|
.165
|
19
|
.042
|
|
9
|
.148
|
20
|
.035
|
|
10
|
.134
|
21
|
.032
|
Specific Gravity Values
|
Hardwood Species
|
Specific Gravity
|
|
Ash
|
0.55
|
|
Aspen
|
0.35
|
|
Basswood
|
0.32
|
|
Beech
|
0.56
|
|
Cherry
|
0.47
|
|
Gum-
|
Black
|
0.46
|
|
Tupelo
|
0.46
|
|
Hickory-
|
Pignut
|
0.66
|
|
Shagbark
|
0.64
|
|
Locust-
|
Black
|
0.66
|
|
Maple-
|
Silver
|
0.44
|
|
Sugar
|
0.56
|
|
Oak-
|
Northern Red
|
0.56
|
|
Southern Red
|
0.52
|
|
Post
|
0.60
|
|
White
|
0.60
|
|
Pecan
|
0.60
|
|
Popular-
|
Yellow
|
0.40
|
|
Walnut
|
0.51
|
Back to Top of Page
Back to Products
 |
"Our reputation has always been based on honesty and integrity. Hard work has been the cornerstone to our service."
- Paul Morette, President |
The Sharp Tool Co., Inc. , 7 Bonazzoli Ave. , Hudson, MA 01749
800-221-5452 / Local: 978-568-9292 / Fax: 978-568-9497 / E-mail: sharp@sharptool.com
|
|
|
|
|
|